The Simply Scary Podcast

Some things refuse to stay buried. A lost love that lingers beyond reason. A final farewell that was never meant to be spoken. A door that should have remained closed—until something on the other side reached out. In tonight’s unnerving episode, host Geoff Sturtevant is joined by special guest Silver Underworld to bring you three tales of obsession, loss, and the terrifying consequences of holding on too tightly. When the past refuses to let go, when love turns into something darker, and when the final chapter is left unwritten… the story doesn’t end. It only waits. "Nicki Didn’t Go to Heaven" by D.D. Wikman – When a young girl survives a near-death experience, her family is overjoyed—until they realize something is off. Her once-warm personality has turned cold, her behavior erratic, and an unsettling presence seems to linger around her. As those closest to her try to dismiss their unease, one thing becomes clear: Nicki came back… but she might not have come back alone. A chilling tale of grief and the unkn